Institutional EYE

Commentary on Corporate Governance Issues

Frauds in the Indian Banking Sector

Indian banking sector reported 12,533 frauds, aggregating to Rs. 181.7 bn in FY17. Such high quantum of frauds can be attributed to weak internal controls, which are capable of leaving an indelible dent on the balance sheet of the bank. Though, the banks are paying high audit fees, it is not necessarily resulting in lower frauds, which means that the overall audit quality needs to be improved.

  1. Bank of Maharashtra reported the highest number of frauds (3,893), followed by ICICI Bank (3,359) and HDFC Bank (2,319). In terms of quantum, PNB (Rs.28.1 bn), Bank of India (Rs.27.7 bn) and SBI (Rs.24.2 bn) fare the worst.

  2. In some banks, while the aggregate quantum is low, the average fraud size if high. This indicates that the sector needs to urgently revisit and strengthen its internal financial controls.

  3. The inability to contain frauds has financial implications. For example, in Bank of Maharashtra, the fraud amount as a % of total assets was 1.02%. Added to a gross NPA of ~19%, this means that more than one-fifth of the asset size is at risk every year due to weak controls and lack of adequate due diligence.

  4. High audit fees signal more audit checks. Yet, despite paying high audit fees, the quantum of fraud in public sector banks tend to be much higher.

  5. The high audit fees in PSBs are a function of larger number of branches), multiple auditors, higher number of physical audits and RBI prescribed rates. But this has failed to improve audit quality. The focus now needs to shift towards strengthening the audit quality by plugging process gaps and streamlining the checks and balances.

  6. While these frauds are an issue of concern across the banking sector, there are a few banks which stand out for being able to control the fraud losses. For example, some private sector banks like IDFC Bank, Dhanlaxmi Bank and DCB Bank, the total quantum of fraud was less than 0.01% of their assets.

For full report, please click here

Recent Posts
Older Posts (till 31 Dec'15)